Posted in Book Reviews

Two Voices One Story by Elaine Rizzo and Amy Masters #BlogTour

A little break from our month’s project today with my stop on the blog tour for Two Voices, One Story, by Elaine Rizzo and her daughter Amy Masters.
I would like to thank Rachel at autoright for including me in this blog tour! Without further ado, here is an extract and my review!

two-voices-one-story
Title: Two Voices, One Story
Author: Elaine Rizzo and Amy Masters
Publisher: Clink Street Publishing
First date of publication: 2017
Format: eARC
Number of pages: 144
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐

This is the true story of a girl called Amy and the English “mother” who adopted her from an institute in China when she was just a baby.

It’s a story about love, family and identity; and the unbreakable bond between mother and daughter.

When Amy came to be adopted in 1999, China’s then notorious one-child policy had given rise to a generation of missing girls. Amy was one of them, destined to life in an orphanage if she was lucky enough to survive. That is, until she was adopted by a loving British couple who were desperate to give her the home she deserved; Elaine and Lee.

In this moving autobiography, Amy and Elaine chart their own personal experiences of their shared adoption story. Theirs is not a political account, but one which is open about the challenges of adopting a child from a foreign country and the long journey that follows; from China to the UK and from infancy through to adolescence, as Amy and her new family learn and grow together.

Now a bright and ambitious young woman on the eve of her eighteenth birthday, Amy is braced for an exciting journey into adulthood, one which her proud mother is delighted to be able to share.

Two Voices, One Story is a frank but uplifting account of the complex adoption process and the profound relationship between a mother and her adopted child.

extract.png

Elaine:

“At first when she went to sleep, Amy would hold her hands firmly clasped together, with her arms close to her body, as though they had been tied together. When she was awake, she would also play little games with her fingers to amuse herself, as this was clearly the only stimulation which had previously been available to her.

Gradually, with gentle care, attention and proper stimulation, Amy’s behavior began to stop and she began to take an interest in what was around her.  

I also wanted Amy to learn to trust me and to realise that I had come into her life to be her mother, so to love and care for her, putting her needs before my own.

When we first got Amy, she didn’t put her arms out to be picked up and cuddled, perhaps because there hadn’t been any point before. One day after we’d been home a few weeks, she spontaneously put her arms up round me, laid her head against my chest and hugged me very tightly.

I knew then that we had made a huge breakthrough in our relationship.”

This extract from the book deals with when Amy was brought home to England and how our mother/daughter began to develop at very first, including some of the effects of her period as a tiny baby in the Welfare Centre.

my-review-red

Two voices One Story brings to life the story of Amy, adopted when she was a baby, and her mother’s journey through the maze that is the whole process of adopting.

Most of their lives are told through Elaine’s narration, which makes sense as baby Amy would have had little communication issues to let people know what she thought about it all! Amy’s insights are light and her voice is filled with the hope of a young and healthy teenager with a life ahead of her.

The beginning made me feel very emotional, as Elaine explains how she ended up choosing to adopt. Her experience was very moving and resonated in me in an extremely personal way. Women were created to make babies, so what happens when they can’t? And does bringing babies into the world make women mothers? All those thoughts came to me as I learned about Elaine’s fate and her decision to have her baby in a different way. I found this first part emotionally intense and cleverly described.

Unfortunately, the story I thought would shed some light on the adoption process itself and the life of parents and child with what some still see as a difference compared to children born from their parents’ activities turned into a beautiful tale of a mother and daughter’s life, but with only little information on the main subject. I had hundreds of questions but the paperwork was rushed two a few pages where I was told it took 2 years in total, and then a baby, a name, a country later and Amy was with her parents. The description of the parents’ first meeting with Amy was adorable, cute, weird and filled with all the emotions you can imagine, but soon, I found myself reading about their wandering into town, wondering if I had missed an episode, the change being so abrupt and unexpected.

The feeling lingered throughout the remaining of the book. It was nice to hear how Amy grew up, but it sounded like any other childhood and I wondered I had grabbed the wrong book. Don’t get me wrong, I am happy Amy wasn’t faced with the issues many adopted children have to face, but I wanted more. I wanted to know when Amy had been told about her adoption, whether or not her parents had chosen to allow her to keep links with her birth country and culture, if and how Amy had reacted to the hardships thrown at her because of her identity, and all those questions you don’t dare to ask to parents of adopted kids sometimes because it doesn’t feel right. It was a nice story, but I was left with so many questions about what made this book special and why they had chosen to emphasize the adoption in the synopsis to eventually let it aside in the story. If you are looking for a sweet tale about mother-daughter bonding, you will probably enjoy Two Voices, One Story, just don’t expect a full adoption experience, as I felt the subject stayed on the superficial side all the way.

about-the-author-red

Elaine Rizzo (Elaine Masters) works in finance as a licensed insolvency practitioner for ClearDebt a company based in Manchester. Her daughter Amy Masters is now eighteen and at college. She enjoys art and design and her ambition is to become a photographer when she graduates. Both now live near Cardigan in West Wales.

You can find other information and reviews about the book in the different blog tour stops!

unnamed

27 thoughts on “Two Voices One Story by Elaine Rizzo and Amy Masters #BlogTour

  1. Great review for this book Donna. It sounds like a really interesting subject; adopting a child from China when the one-child policy was enforced, and all that entails, it’s just a shame that wasn’t more developed in this book. It’s something I would have been interested in as well but as it is sounds like it was brushed past to make room for the families development together, if that makes sense.
    Still it sounds like a good book overall, and I love the cover design as well. 🙂

    Like

    1. It was a nice book about a mother and a daughter, but I had really picked it for the adoption side so it was a bit of a letdown. It felt me with the idea adopting was somehow easier than we thought and raising your adopted child a piece of cake, it was a weird feeling.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. When I read the beginning of your review and the blurb I thought it would have more about the adoption, especially considering it would have been an interesting angle to talk more about as well.
        That kind of makes it sound like a light read, a book where nothing seems to go wrong, which don’t get me wrong can be nice every now and again but not if maybe you expected more.

        Like

  2. A great review as always. I haven’t heard of this book before. I think it would be a book that I would be in two minds whether to read or not,as it could be too difficult a read (for me). I, as did you, would want to hear more about the full story of adoption. However, I can imagine for a lot of readers, perhaps who have their own children would see this book in a more simple way of (like you said), the mother / child relationship.
    Amanda.

    Like

    1. It definitely is a nice story about how mother and daughter create their bonds and go through life together, but the adoption side is way to light to satisfy any reader in search of answers about it. Thank you for visiting the blog! xxx

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Interesting Donna – I was drawn to the synopsis of this because of the adoption so I’m glad you drew attention to the fact that while a lovely reconstruction of a mother/daughter bond this information isn’t the lead factor in the book. Great review!

    Like

    1. Thank you! I found the blurb to be somehow misleading. It was nice to read about the mother-daughter relationship but I really had picked this story based on the adoption side so I was disappointed.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Wow, this book sounds interesting! I’m sorry that it seems like the adoption theme is explored only superficially, but I’m really intrigued by the mother-daughter side of things. Like you, though, I’d probably assume it’s an adoption story given the blurb (and the title) and end up disappointed if I hadn’t known it’s more about the parent-child relationship later on, so thanks for letting us know about that.

    Great review, Donna – I’ll be keeping an eye out for this book for sure. ❤

    Like

    1. Thank you ❤ Yeah, I really wanted to explore the adoption process so it was a bit of a disappointment for me, but it was a nice read and Elaine and Amy's voices were genuine.

      Like

  5. I’m sorry you didn’t get answers to all of your questions in this novel. I wouldn’t mind it lacked in describing the adoption procedure but I would have liked some ‘personal experience’ like telling someone they were adopted. I think that’s very difficult to do and to hear and I would have liked to see the thoughts before and the conversation itself too. Great review!

    Like

  6. Very fair and ever insightful review. I am not sure that I would have connected with this even as much as you did, although it is certainly any interesting topic to challenge that has the potential to shed light on perhaps a lesser known subject. Sounds slightly like that potential was a bit lost here though?

    Like

    1. Yep, definitely the potential was lost along the way. The adoption felt like a subplot used once in a while, and the rest of the story focused on a somewhat regular and “boring” life we all get to live.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Fabulous review, Donna! I do enjoy stories with mother/daughter bonding… or good family relationships in general. And I like that it’s a bit on the shorter side, which means it may be a quick read for me. It sounds like an interesting read, and I’ll definitely be checking it out!

    Like

  8. Great review!
    I think, same as yourself, I would end up with all of the unanswered questions.
    The book itself sounds like a great celebration of family dynamics though and I think there’s never enough nice stories out there around real human relationships.

    Like

    1. Thank you! ❤ It's true that nice stories are less present, so it wasn't a boring thing to read, but I can't get over the disappointment of not diving deeper into the adoption.

      Like

  9. Such a beautiful cover! Great review; I agree it’s a shame the actual adoption process doesn’t play a bigger role in the story… Especially since the blurb kind of hints at the fact that the story would talk about the complex adoption process in the first place.

    Like

  10. Aw man, sucks that the whole adoption theme wasn’t exploited further. Having heard from parents who have adopted children and how their bond is sometimes as powerful and strong as any biological relationship, I thought the book would dive into this and deliver something that would even bring a tear or two to the reader! Excellent review, Donna! 🙂

    – Lashaan

    Like

    1. Thank you! I was so disappointed in the fact the adoption felt like a detail. I did not want to read a nice bounding story, I wanted the raw, difficulties and happy moments of this life-changing event!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s